Elaina Shinn

Elaina Shinn is a full-time Associate Broker at Old Mill Properties with over a decade of experience in the real estate industry. She began her career in 2014 as an assistant to the Broker before earning her real estate license and quickly establishing herself as a dedicated and driven professional. Balancing sales, administrative work, and managing the vacation rental department, Elaina gained invaluable industry knowledge before stepping into her current role as Associate [...]

Elaina Shinn is a full-time Associate Broker at Old Mill Properties with over a decade of experience in the real estate industry. She began her career in 2014 as an assistant to the Broker before earning her real estate license and quickly establishing herself as a dedicated and driven professional. Balancing sales, administrative work, and managing the vacation rental department, Elaina gained invaluable industry knowledge before stepping into her current role as Associate Broker.

With a deep understanding of the many facets of real estate, Elaina is committed to delivering top-quality service while helping her customers & clients achieve their real estate goals. She holds multiple industry designations, including Graduate of the REALTOR® Institute (GRI), Certified Buyer Representative (CBR), and Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR). As of 2025, Elaina has closed over $50 million in sales and has successfully guided 220+ transactions.

A lifelong resident of the Newfound Lake Region, Elaina is an expert on the local market and has a deep appreciation for the lake and its surrounding communities. Her extensive knowledge and passion for the area make her a trusted resource for buyers and sellers alike.

Outside of real estate, Elaina enjoys fishing, spending time by the ocean, and exploring the beauty of New England with her husband, Colby, and their two dogs, Juno and Rosie. She looks forward to assisting you with your real estate needs!